
~ The Val delle Rose winery just may be the crown jewel of the Cecchi Estates ~
It’s been over a month since the popular Tuscan Snips series graced these pages with the release of Volume 5. Today, I continue the trend with a revisit on a few exciting reds but also some newly released whites and rose. So let’s get to it!
Vernaccia may be Tuscany’s greatest white wine and certainly it has earned its DOCG status. Along with Vermentino, the inertia behind producing great Vernaccia has never been stronger. One of the producers leading this quality revolution is Campochiarenti. When I last visited Tuscany, pre-pandemic, winemaker Daniele Rosti gushed over his soon to be released 2018 Vernaccia. What he didn’t tell me then, was that he had an ace up his sleeve.

~ San Gimignano lies in the distance in this view from Campochiarenti ~
The 2018 Campochiarenti Vernaccia di San Gimignano Riserva continues the progression of winemaker Daniele Rosti’s Vitiarium collection. A medium golden color in the glass, this wine, which spent almost twice as long aging in steel tanks as required by the DOCG regulations, has picked up additional color from the extended contact with the lees.
On the nose, this wine screams Campochiarenti terroir. The laser beams of lemon and white peaches are met by flinty mineral and aquiline aromas. The complexity is very interesting. After extended aeration, white flowers peek through also but the mineral quality is dominant at the moment.
On the palate, the powdery, mineral traces are dominant. As a result of the extended aging, the rounder, fuller body of the wine versus the normal Vernaccia makes for an interesting comparison. Lemon, peach and herbal notes round out the flavor. It will be interesting to watch this wine evolve. I suspect the fruit character will assert itself more in the future. 92 points. Available directly from the winery.

~ Tuscan Snips: Continuing his Vitiarium Collection with his 2018 Vernaccia Riserva ~
In my exclusive series on Vino Nobile, I profiled two wines from Tenuta Vallocaia. The winery was so excited that someone was bringing well deserved attention to Vino Nobile, they contacted me personally to thank me for my efforts. As a result, they sent a few more wines my way. The first is gorgeous and perfect for the coming patio season.
The 2020 Tenuta Vallocaia Gemella Rosato is an intriguing blend of Sangiovese and Syrah. Despite the crazy year that 2020 was, the winemakers I’ve spoken to were quick to mention how good the vintage was. We’re seeing the first results of that. This is fresh, vibrant and delicious. Flavors and aromas of strawberry, watermelon, white peaches and flowers are exuberant. Fresh, crisp and long, this paired well with a variety of dishes including calamari fritti, grilled octopus and burrata cheese. Bello! This is due for release very soon. 89 points. Find this wine.

~ The Tenuta Vallocaia Rosato is 75% Sangivoese and 25% Syrah ~
I last tasted the next wine almost one year ago. At the time, it was just about to be released. One year later, it’s still drinking beautifully. While we wait for the 2020 to be released, Tuscan Snip your way into this one…
The 2019 Val delle Rose Vermentino Litorale has never disappointed. The last time I tried this crisp white from Andrea Cecchi, we paired it with my wonderful pasta con piselli recipe that Castellina inspired.

~ Inspired by a Trattoria in Castellina, I have reverse engineered this wonderful recipe that screams Spring ~
In the glass, the wine is a pale straw color. On the nose, this wine is replete with pineapple, lemon grass, tropical fruit and flinty stones. Floral too with an almost perfumed nature; exotic notes of Gardenia. On the palate, it’s crisp and vibrant with pineapple, lemon peel, stone and mineral character. I just love it! 92 points. Find this wine.

~ As you perhaps can tell, I pulled this wine to pair with Carbonara ~
Sometimes we try hard to reconcile scores, find wines that have broad appeal, excellent value, noteworthy complexity and aging potential. I’m beginning to think that if Franco Bernabei is involved, I should just say screw it and buy the wine! The man knows how to craft Sangiovese. I first reviewed the next wine in September of 2020 and it’s even better now. It’s a true Cellar Sentinel.
The 2016 Lornano Chianti Classico is 100% Sangiovese that is vinified in stainless steel and then aged in French oak for 12 months. A further 6 months bottle age follows before release. This boasts a deep ruby color with violet reflections throughout. Crushed cherry, pipe tobacco, and blue flowers mark the enticing nose. On the palate, this is juicy, fresh and vibrant. New leather and toasted hazelnut add complexity to the sapid, mouthwatering cherry fruit that coats the palate front to back. As it gains more air, it gains more weight and roundness. What more could you want from a wine that’s $14.99? I know a few of my followers purchased a case of this beauty. Stock up! 93 points. Find this wine.

~ This wine has begun to evolve in a striking way. It’s a Cellar Sentinel, a killer value and worthy of your cellar ~
Finally, I’m going to close with an update on a wine that I know a lot of people enjoy and have in their cellars. It’s one thing to read an initial review and purchase the wine based upon that. But then what? Many times you’re left alone to judge (or gamble) for yourself about when the right time to open that great bottle may be. And if it’s your only bottle, well then you may have a heck of a problem.
The 2015 Antinori Tignanello is no doubt a stunning wine and one of the best Super Tuscans from the vintage. It’s what I would expect and its delivered. I last wrote about this wine in 2018 and it was gorgeous then. Three years removed from that review, it’s time to let Tignanello rest.
In the glass, a deep ruby leads to violet reflections. Everything has been toned down with this wine on both the nose and palate. It’s not nearly as complex as it showed upon release. Well, it likely is, but it needs its slumber like an awkward, cranky teenager.
Primary flavors and aromas of crushed cherry are met with leather and dusty earth notes. I’m left thinking about what I wrote in my original review: “If there’s a knock here, it’s that this is drinking so well now I almost wonder how long it will age. Perhaps it’ll shut down and emerge as something different. I don’t know, but given my long history with Tignanello, I’ve no trepidation whatsoever about holding this until it’s 15 years old and enjoying the journey along the way.”
It’s now 6 years old and I don’t think I’ll check in on it again until it’s at least 10. If I have the patience. 93 points at the current moment. Find this wine.

~ It’s time to let the 15 Tignanello age for about 5 years ~
That concludes this edition of Tuscan Snips. What’s coming next? Well, Newsletter Subscribers are going to get an exclusive look at some 2015 Brunello that I’ve just re-tasted. They’re also going to get a glimpse of some 2016 Brunello.
Here, I’ll be spotlighting some new releases from Gagliole, writing Part 1 of that “mystery bottle” blind tasting and a few other surprises are planned. Stay tuned!
Salute!
As always I’m smacking my lips thinking about wonderful cuisine to pair with wines but serendipity is in the air. I got to thinking about the sole surviving 2015 Tignanello I saw earlier this year at a deli and was looking at old reviews then read this, so how about that? A couple of questions though: First, given your present observation, do you recommend grabbing the 2015 if it’s still there (price is high though) or a slow-to-move stash of 2016s in a small shop where they’re likely to remain a while?
Paul, I’ve also reviewed the 16 here, just search for it. I would think the 16 is costlier than the 15 but if it’s not, I’d get that. It’s gorgeous too.
Great! They definitely inflated the price of the 2015 (I’d like to say it’s $175) and the 2016s are a little pricier but not that high. I did read the 2016 review and it left me more excited about that, especially since I would not have to drive far. The 2018s seem like the next good vintage, any thoughts? I also look forward to the 2015 and 2016 Brunello reports.
Hi Paul, yikes – yes at $175 it’s a major pass. That’s just too damn much money for Tig. I got these 2015s for less than $90 and the 2016 in Italy was something like $80 Euro. Unless the price is compelling (and I doubt it will be) or unless it’s special to you or you have a vertical going, I’d skip 2018 Tig. Just like I skipped 2014. 2018 was a very hot year and I just can’t see spending primo dollars on wines like this unless they’re coming from excellent years. I plan on holding off until 2019 for Tig but even then, it may be $150 by that time. A big turn off. Especially considering other available options. $175 is very high for Tig. – even outside of my market. Where are you located?
Hi John,
Thank you for the recommendations, I agree, with so many great 2015 and 2016 Brunello, and 2016 Barolo to tackle, skipping the really expensive, less than ideal vintages is probably the most cost-effective. I am in SOCAL, Riverside to be exact. The best-priced wine shop is Hi-Time Wine Cellars in Costa Mesa, I enjoy the drive and know many of the wine specialists. The next great places are in Culver City/LA: LA Wine Merchants, and especially the Wine House. The latter has slightly higher prices but their selection is amazing and a fun place to browse. Then, and you have commented on their high prices, Ealtaly LA has a great selection but I only buy when on sale or I know it is a good deal. Finally, a small but surprisingly good liquor store in Riverside is sitting on some gems, including 2016 Tignanello, Ornellaia and Sassicaia. Prices are respectively $160, $250 and $300.
Correction: LA Wine Co., not LA Wine Exchange
Hi John,
Another informative and interesting volume of Tuscan Snips. As usual the review has been desiring several of the wines. I have said it before but will say again, I must get Campochiarenti on my list of bi-annual direct buys. Would love to have the Vernaccia Riserva in the cellar. One of the next trips to Tuscany will include a scheduled visit to them. Val delle Rose products are always enjoyable to me.
I have never tasted the Lornano but based on your review and value that may fill a spot in my cellar of an enjoyable Chianti in that price point range. Will order today!
Thank you
Hey Joe,
Yes, I think the value to many of these wines is compelling. You will enjoy Campochiarenti when you visit. Daniele is a great winemaker and he exudes that passion. You will really appreciate him and he’s small, like Campotondo etc.. You taste in his back yard. Salute!